Category Archives: News

Income Tax & Your Settlement Agreement: 7 Things to Consider

No matter what kind of employment problem you are facing—e.g. a claim for wrongful dismissal, constructive dismissal, or a human rights complaint—you may ultimately decide to settle your case for some form of compensation, rather than proceeding to a hearing. In that case, it is worth taking the time to think about the best way to structure your settlement agreement because different kinds of agreements and different kinds of compensation can lead to a wide range of tax consequences.

Seven key considerations in structuring a settlement agreement:

  1. Compensation for lost income is fully taxable under the Income Tax Act because it is treated like any other employment income.
  2. Compensation for the loss of employment, such as severance pay or reasonable notice (see: What is reasonable notice? ), is also fully taxable under the Income Tax Act. Unless certain limited exceptions apply, these kinds of compensation are considered “retiring allowances” under the Income Tax Act.
  3. If part of your employment with your employer took place prior to 1996, you can roll a portion of a retiring allowance payment into an RRSP. The roll-over is tax-free, and you do not need existing room in your RRSP to roll-over eligible amounts. Similar rules exist for any part of your employment that took place prior to 1989.
  4. Compensation for damages, such as for mental distress or pain and suffering, are not subject to tax. Damages must be reasonable, however, and there must be some proof to support the claim for damages. The claim for damages also has to be independent from the loss of employment. If the mental distress was caused by the loss of employment, then any damages for mental distress will be considered part of employment income or a retiring allowance and will be taxable.
  5.  Damages for human rights violations are also non-taxable. Like damages for mental distress, they must be reasonable and similar to what a human rights tribunal might award. Be especially careful because, in some jurisdictions, legislation puts a maximum cap on damages for human rights in a tribunal’s award. In those cases, the amount characterized as human rights damages in the settlement agreement cannot go over the cap.
  6.  Compensation for counselling services is not subject to tax. “Counselling services” have been defined to include job placement, re-employment, and retirement counselling services.
  7.  Compensation for legal fees is deductible for employees. Where the payment is made directly from the employer to the employee’s legal adviser, this amount is non-taxable.

Conclusion

Both employees and employers need to take time to consider the structure of the settlement agreement and how to characterize any compensation changing hands. While the parties can reach agreements that maximize the benefits of the settlement for both sides, any settlement must be reasonable and grounded in the facts of the case. An unreasonable settlement agreement may be reviewed by the Canada Revenue Agency. For help determining the best structure of your settlement agreement, you should seek advice from an employment lawyer.

We are here to help: Consult one of our experienced employment lawyers at Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne and Yazbeck LLP to assist you in developing or reviewing a settlement agreement for your employment claim. 

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

 

David Yazbeck to moderate panel on “Harassment and the toxic work environment: Examining rights and remedies”

On December 17, 2014, David Yazbeck will be moderating the Lancaster House Panel on Harassment and the Toxic Work Environment: Examining Rights and Remedies. This is one of a series of audio conferences presented by Lancaster House on a variety of topics affecting the workplace. Mr. Yazbeck has often acted as a moderator and speaker on these conferences.

For more information about this particular audio conference, visit the Lancaster House website here.

 

What To Do If (and When) Your Claim For Long Term Disability (“LTD”) Insurance is Denied

The process for successfully claiming long-term disability (“LTD”) insurance benefits can be complex and lengthy (See our article on “Navigating your Claim for Long-Term Disability (LTD) Insurance”). Unfortunately, part of that process often includes responding to a denial of your claim by the insurance company. This article summarizes the key steps to take if your disability claim has been denied.

When are you likely to be turned down for LTD insurance benefits? 

LTD policies usually have two different kinds of coverage.  For the first two years, the coverage provided is commonly known as “own occupation” coverage, meaning that if you can’t do the primary functions of your job, you are entitled to benefits.  After this period, the coverage often changes to “any occupation” coverage, meaning you will only continue to receive benefits if you cannot perform any job for which you are suited because of your background and not just your old job.  Claims for LTD benefits can be denied either before coverage starts, or after two years, when the definition changes.

Key Tips for Responding to a Denial of a Claim for LTD insurance benefits:

1. Don’t give up!

Many people are discouraged when they are turned down for LTD benefits.  They should not take it personally.  Refusals are often a part of the process, and are not necessarily an indication of whether your claim for LTD benefits will ultimately be determined.

2. Internal Appeals

It is possible to appeal internally to the insurance company.  The insurance company may alter its decision and provide LTD benefits, if new medical evidence is provided.  Unfortunately, in many cases, the internal appeal does not change the initial refusal.

3. Suing the insurance company for your LTD benefits

Often the only way to obtain benefits from an insurance company after your disability claim has been refused is to sue.  For many people, the prospect of litigating with an insurance company, particularly when you are disabled and without income, seems impossible.  We recommend that disabled people seek good advice from competent, experienced lawyers, who can properly advise you on your rights.  With the help of good counsel, you can enforce your rights and obtain the benefits for which you have paid.

Counsel work either on an hourly basis, or on a contingency basis (a percentage of the amount recovered).  Many people prefer to hire counsel on a contingency basis, because there is no payment of legal fees unless and until there is recovery from the insurance company.

In all cases, it is strongly advised that you seek advice as quickly as possible after benefits are refused, as there are time limits which may cause you to lose the right to sue the insurance company.

4.  Opportunities for Mediation

Although it may be necessary to start legal proceedings to enforce your legal rights, it is important to know that most cases settle at mediation.   Mediation is a negotiation session conducted by an experienced neutral facilitator.  The mediator will explore with the parties whether it is in their best interests to settle the claim for a lump sum or by reinstating the insured worker’s benefits.  The mediator will have the parties explore the risks and costs of litigation and help them to determine whether a settlement is preferable to carrying on to Trial.

Conclusion

If you have been turned down for LTD benefits, please do not give up.  If you retain good, experienced counsel and follow their advice, you stand a good chance of obtaining a satisfactory solution.

We are here to help navigate the LTD application process. Consult one of our experienced Long Term Disability lawyers at Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne and Yazbeck LLP if you are considering making a claim for disability benefits or if your claim for benefits has been denied. 

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

Board finds violation of statutory freeze

On April 23, 2013 the Public Service Labour Relations Board (PSLRB) upheld the Public Service Alliance of Canada’s complaint against the Treasury Board and Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA). The PSLRB found that the Treasury Board and CBSA violated the statutory freeze on terms and conditions of employment by terminating a long-standing practice of granting union officers full-time union leave with pay. This important decision clarifies the law on the statutory freeze period in the federal public sector and establishes the PSLRB’s approach to the issue of the time limits for making statutory freeze complaints. The case was argued by Andrew Raven with assistance from Dayna Steinfeld of Ravenlaw.

Welcome to Writing for Working People!

We are proud to introduce Ravenlaw’s new blog, Writing for Working People! Our firm has over 125 combined years of experience representing employees and unions in all aspects of labour and employment law. We have specialized expertise in a variety of areas, including federal public service employment, wrongful dismissal, human rights, administrative law, judicial review, and disability benefits. This blog is part of a new effort to share the benefit of that expertise with our clients and the community through our new Ravenlaw website. We have also posted the first group in a series of articles providing general legal information on topics in our areas of expertise.

On Writing for Working People, we will be providing regular updates and commentary on issues that impact workers’ rights, including: recent court decisions, changes to labour and employment-related legislation, and other legal and political topics affecting unions and workers across the country. Please check back regularly for the latest posts!

 

 

James Cameron and Andrew Astritis present at 2013 Accommodation law Conference

On May 2, 2013, James Cameron and Andrew Astritis each presented at the 2013 Accommodation Law Conference in Ottawa, sponsored by Labour Law Online.ca, the Centre for Labour-Management Development.  Their presentations addressed Workplace Policies and the Duty to Accommodate, Discipline, Discharge and the Disabled Employee, Accommodating Family Status, Disabilities requiring special Accommodation, as well as a host of other issues:
http://labourlawonline.ca/main.jsp?p=seminar_desc&seminarid=185&bndid=3&st=3

Navigating your Claim for Long-Term Disability (“LTD”) Insurance

If you cannot work due to illness or injury, you may assume your long-term disability (“LTD”) insurance benefits will provide a secure source of income replacement to cover your financial obligations and also to provide peace of mind, allowing you to focus on your health instead of financial worries.

While this may be the understanding, disabled employees are often overwhelmed by daunting administrative hurdles when they attempt to access LTD benefits. They may also become discouraged when their disability claim is denied (See our article on “What to do if your LTD claim is denied”). The following are some key tips to navigating the claim for a long-term disability claim.

Keys to Navigating Your Long-Term Disability Claim:

 1. Apply

 Submit an application for benefits as soon as you and your doctor determine that you can no longer perform the essential duties of your job. Involve your treating professionals and have the discussion with them about whether or not your illness or condition is interfering with your ability to work.

 2. Fill out the claim forms completely

You should request a copy of the benefits policy describing the details of your coverage and the application forms from your employer or the insurer. When completing the application, be sure that you do not overlook or choose not to answer questions on the forms. If something does not apply to your particular situation, note that on the form. Avoid creating the situation where an incomplete application causes significant delays. Double-check and answer all the questions in the application correctly.

3. Submit detailed medical support with your initial application 

The insurance company only requires a short form called the Attending Physician’s Statement, to be filled out by your doctor as part of the application. However, the insurance company will most likely ask for more detailed medical information later on. If possible, expedite this process by submitting comprehensive reports from your medical specialists.

Ideally, a more detailed report should specifically address why you cannot work, especially if your health condition is also being affected by conditions such as depression, anxiety, chronic pain, PTSD or other invisible disabilities which do not show up on an x-ray. Speak to those involved in your treatment to describe how you are functionally limited by your symptoms, the treatment you are receiving, and whether you have cooperated with their treatment recommendations. The information should focus on your accommodation needs, such as how much time off of work you need, and whether you are able to perform the actual duties of your own or an alternative occupation.

4. Cooperate with the insurance company’s requests 

Respond to your insurance company’s requests in a timely manner, within their specified deadlines.  Carefully consider what medical and health information you agree to allow the insurer to share with your employer and others involved in your claim. The insurer does have an obligation to respect your privacy rights.

5. Stick with It.  

The biggest mistake you can make is to abandon your long-term disability claim prematurely. The claims process can be difficult and the delays and complexities may lead you to want to abandon the process, particularly because this is happening when you are unwell and at your most vulnerable, making it a very difficult process to navigate successfully without assistance and guidance. Seeking legal advice and representation can help you to navigate this process, and ensure that you have help each step of the way.

 We are here to help navigate the long-term disability claim process. Consult one of our experienced Long Term Disability lawyers at Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne and Yazbeck LLP if you are considering making a claim for disability benefits or if your disability claim for benefits has been denied. 

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

Federal Court Quashes Minister Ordered Forced Vote

On August 30, 2013, the Federal Court of Canada quashed an Order made by the Minister of Heritage, James Moore, and cancelled a forced vote on the Canada Border Services Agency’s (“CBSA”) employees in the Frontière/Border (“FB”) group.

The Minister’s Order was made following a request by Treasury Board President Tony Clement for a forced vote on the employer’s final offer, dated May 6, 2013. Minister Moore ordered the vote without consulting or giving notice to the Public Service Alliance of Canada (“PSAC”), the certified bargaining agent representing the 7 000 plus employees affected.

PSAC successfully judicially reviewed the decision before the Federal Court of Canada. In her decision, Justice Mary Gleason emphasized the importance of the vote on PSAC’s interests. Justice Gleason found that “it would be difficult to find a decision that might more deeply affect a trade union’s interests than the decision to order a vote among bargaining unit members” and concluded that PSAC was entitled to adequate notice of the employer’s request for a forced vote and a meaningful opportunity to respond to it.

Justice Gleason noted each side’s duty to engage in good faith collective bargaining and set aside the Minister’s order, without remitting the matter back to the Minister for reconsideration: “the decision of the Minister to order a vote among the employees in the FB bargaining unit on the Employer’s final offer will be set aside. And, since the decision directing the vote is being quashed, the activities currently being undertaken by the PSLRB to conduct that vote must cease as there is no longer any decision to authorize them.”

PSAC was represented by Andrew Raven and Wassim Garzouzi of Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck LLP/s.r.l.

Read the PSAC’s press release.

Ravenlaw.com introduces new Resources section

As part of the new and exciting changes to our website, we are pleased to announce the introduction of the Resources section, which will include informative articles on topics in our areas of expertise, and Writing for Working People, our new blog. We hope that these new resources will provide our clients and the community with relevant and useful information about workers’ rights in all areas of labour, employment and human rights law. 

The first group of articles is on the topic of Disability Benefits. Several of our lawyers have recently given informational sessions on long-term disability benefits and other related issues, including at the Maplesoft Centre and the Ottawa Fibromyalgia Support Group. We have now posted a group of articles, providing general information on these topics. Similar articles on other legal topics will be soon to follow. 

We have also introduced a new blog, Writing for Working People. On this blog, we will be providing regular updates and commentary on issues that impact workers’ rights, including: recent court decisions, changes to labour and employment-related legislation, and other legal and political topics affecting unions and workers across the country. 

Please check back regularly as we continue to update these new resources!

 

Congratulations to Morgan Rowe on the publication of her book on Disability Rights

Morgan Rowe recently published a book with Professor Ravi Malhotra of the University of Ottawa Law School entitled Exploring Disability Identity and Disability Rights through Narratives: Finding a Voice of Their Own. The book examines the life stories of twelve Canadians with physical disabilities, using their narratives to explore whether an advocacy identity helps or hinders dealing with systemic barriers for disabled people in education, employment and transportation.

We all congratulate Morgan on this significant achievement.

Please click here for more information on the book from the publisher.

http://www.routledge.com/books/details/9780415532358/