Category Archives: News

Ravenlaw.com introduces new Resources section

As part of the new and exciting changes to our website, we are pleased to announce the introduction of the Resources section, which will include informative articles on topics in our areas of expertise, and Writing for Working People, our new blog. We hope that these new resources will provide our clients and the community with relevant and useful information about workers’ rights in all areas of labour, employment and human rights law. 

The first group of articles is on the topic of Disability Benefits. Several of our lawyers have recently given informational sessions on long-term disability benefits and other related issues, including at the Maplesoft Centre and the Ottawa Fibromyalgia Support Group. We have now posted a group of articles, providing general information on these topics. Similar articles on other legal topics will be soon to follow. 

We have also introduced a new blog, Writing for Working People. On this blog, we will be providing regular updates and commentary on issues that impact workers’ rights, including: recent court decisions, changes to labour and employment-related legislation, and other legal and political topics affecting unions and workers across the country. 

Please check back regularly as we continue to update these new resources!

 

Congratulations to Morgan Rowe on the publication of her book on Disability Rights

Morgan Rowe recently published a book with Professor Ravi Malhotra of the University of Ottawa Law School entitled Exploring Disability Identity and Disability Rights through Narratives: Finding a Voice of Their Own. The book examines the life stories of twelve Canadians with physical disabilities, using their narratives to explore whether an advocacy identity helps or hinders dealing with systemic barriers for disabled people in education, employment and transportation.

We all congratulate Morgan on this significant achievement.

Please click here for more information on the book from the publisher.

http://www.routledge.com/books/details/9780415532358/

Bill 18, Strengthening employment laws: strong mandate, or rushed half-measures?

Employment legislation has a huge impact on workers’ rights. However, employment lawyers know all too well that well-meaning legislation often fails to translate into better conditions for workers, because some workers are excluded from its protection, or it is difficult to enforce.

Tomorrow, the Ontario government is set to pass Bill 18, a sweeping bill intended to strengthen existing labour and employment laws. While many of the proposed changes are to be welcomed, the proposals fail to address the problems with enforcing employees’ existing rights.

Ontario’s Bill 18: Stronger Workplaces for a Stronger Economy Act

Bill 18, which passed Second Reading in the Ontario legislature on October 29, is what is known as an ‘omnibus’ bill: it includes amendments to several existing statutes affecting labour, employment, workers’ compensation and health and safety. Some of the highlights include:

  • Enhancing the protections for temporary foreign workers in Ontario;
  • Requiring employers to provide employees with information regarding their rights under the Employment Standards Act;
  • Removing the $10,000 cap on recovery for unpaid wages through a Ministry of Labour order to pay, and extending the time limit to recover wages;
  • Amending the definition of “worker” in the Occupational Health and Safety Act to extend coverage to co-op students, trainees and other unpaid workers;
  • Indexing minimum wage to the rate of inflation.

Motion for time allocation passed, limiting debate

The Liberals brought a motion on Monday, October 27 for “time allocation”, limiting debate of Bill 18 and expediting its passage. The government justified this move as following through on the strong mandate the Liberals received in the last provincial election to end the delays in passing important legislation.

Opposition members questioned this rationale for limiting debate, and emphasized that Bill 18 is incredibly important to workers across Ontario, meaning all affected parties, including precarious workers and interest groups, should have an opportunity to be heard. Peggy Sattler, an NDP MPP who has tabled her own private member’s bill seeking to improve rights for unpaid interns, pointed out that a curtailed debate will prevent discussion of the shortcomings of Bill 18, including the fact that enforcement of employment rights remains difficult for vulnerable employees, such as unpaid interns and migrant workers, because it is dependent on employee complaints.

Important rights may go unrealized

On the whole, Bill 18 is to be lauded for extending certain protections to various groups of vulnerable workers, who are currently excluded from employment regulations. These changes are encouraging as they appear to reflect a genuine desire to increase workers’ access to rights such as redress for unpaid wages, workers’ compensation, and health and safety. However, without a robust method of enforcing these rights, they may go unrealized for many workers.

Existing enforcement mechanisms based on employee complaints are problematic, because they depend on workers, who are often in a vulnerable position, knowing their rights and coming forward. Many workers may be unwilling to bring a complaint for fear of negative consequences in their employment. Our firm’s social justice intern last year, Daniel Tucker-Simmons, wrote a comprehensive report  on the problems with the current enforcement model for the Broadbent Institute.

As discussed in that report, an important step to improve the enforcement of employment standards legislation would be to repeal provisions enacted by the 2010 Open for Business Act that require employees to raise an alleged violation of the Employment Standards Act with their employer before being allowed to file a complaint with the Ministry of Labour. That amendment was widely criticized at the time, as most workers would be unwilling to directly confront their employers about violations of their rights. Repealing this requirement would improve the chances that the proposed new rights will be adequately enforced. Unfortunately, the limited debate of Bill 18 will prevent these and other issues from being the subject of appropriate discussion and review.

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

 

 

RCBY Represents CARFAC and RAAV before the CAPPRT

Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck LLP/s.r.l. is proud to represent the Canadian Artists Representation (CARFAC) and the Regroupement des artistes en arts visuels du Québec (RAAV) pro bono before the Canadian Artists and Producers Professional Relations Tribunal.

CARFAC and RAAV, which represent visual artists in Canada and Québec, have filed a complaint of bad faith bargaining against the National Gallery of Canada (NGC). The complaint was filed after the NGC refused to discuss minimum exhibition and reproduction fees for visual artists, following five years of ongoing negotiations.  CARFAC and RAAV are seeking to ensure that Canadian visual artists receive minimum fees for the exhibition and reproduction of their works by the NGC.

The Complaint was heard initially on October 26-27, 2010, and the hearing is scheduled to resume at 8:30 on December 2-3, 2010 at the Competition Tribunal hearing room.  David Yazbeck and Erin O’Hara are counsel.  Argument is expected to start Friday morning.

Tax System Undermines Pay Equity Settlement

Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck LLP/s.r.l. is currently representing the Public Service Alliance of Canada (“PSAC”) and Cathy Murphy before the Federal Court in an application for judicial review of a decision of the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal.

The Tribunal dismissed the human rights complaint filed by the PSAC and Ms Murphy that alleged that the Canada Revenue Agency (“CRA”) discriminated against individuals who had received lump-sum pay equity payments in the year 2000 and were taxed on the full amount that same year. Consequently, most individuals who received lump-sum awards paid more taxes than individuals who received their wages in the years they were earned.

Provisions in the Income Tax Act allowed individuals to spread the lump-sum award over past years but triggered the CRA to charge compound interest on the amounts that would have been paid, thus reducing the actual value of the payment ordered. The effect of CRA’s actions was to undermine full pay equity for thousands of PSAC members.

The application was heard on January 11, 2011 at the Federal Court. David Yazbeck is counsel. Justice Michel Beaudry reserved judgment.

In the Ottawa Citizen: Feds, public service union battle over pay equity back taxes

RCBY wins Abuse of Authority case at Federal Court of Appeal

The Federal Court of Appeal recently released its decision in Kane v. Attorney General of Canada, the first case before that Court involving a decision of the Public Service Staffing Tribunal. In its ruling, the Court of Appeal overturned the Tribunal’s decision, which had rejected Robert Kane’s argument that his employer had committed an abuse of authority in failing appoint him to his reclassified position.

In allowing Mr Kane’s appeal, the Federal Court of Appeal concluded that the Tribunal had acted unreasonably in finding that it was irrelevant whether the position in question was a new or reclassified position, given that this distinction served as the basis for the employer’s decision to proceed by way of an advertised appointment process.  Importantly, the Federal Court of Appeal also rejected the narrow test for abuse of authority proposed by the Attorney General of Canada, ruling that this test was at odds with the ordinary meaning of the provision and the purpose of the legislation.

Mr Kane, a member of the Public Service Alliance of Canada (“PSAC”) was represented by Andrew Raven and Andrew Astritis. The full text of the Federal Court of Appeal’s decision is available here.

2011 Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck Human Rights/Social Justice Internship

Our firm is renewing its partnership with the University of Ottawa and continues its commitment and funding to the Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck LLP/s.r.l. Human Rights/Social Justice Internship which provides a student with an opportunity to work full time over the summer as an intern in the areas of social justice and human rights.

This is a program that we are very proud of as it gives students excellent experience in these areas but also provides legal support to social justice organizations. This year, the host organizations are the Public Service Alliance of Canada (PSAC) and the Ottawa Riverkeeper.

If your organization works in the areas of social justice and human rights and you are interested in having an intern in the future, please contact David Yazbeck at 613-567-2901.

RCBY challenging Policy excluding employees with Type 1 Diabetes

Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck LLP/s.r.l. represented Bronwyn Cruden, a Canadian International Development Agency (“CIDA”) aid worker and member of the Public Service Alliance of Canada (“PSAC”) before the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal.

Ms Cruden filed a complaint with the Tribunal in 2008 against CIDA and Health Canada after being denied a field posting in Afghanistan because she had Type 1 Diabetes. Despite her status as a “rising star” within CIDA and having successfully completed physical examinations and independent specialized medical assessments deeming her fit for posting, Health Canada refused to recommend her for medical clearance.  CIDA, which has the authority to overrule Health Canada recommendations, refused to post her to Afghanistan or to provide suitable accommodation.  Health Canada’s policy prohibits federal government employees with Type 1 diabetes from being posted to Afghanistan and other regions deemed to be “hostile”. Ms Cruden seeks to change the policy and receive compensation for lost wages and opportunities.

The hearing was held from January 17 to February 3, 2011. Bronwyn Cruden was represented by Alison Dewar and Erin O’Hara.

James Cameron to Speak at OBA Conference on Harassment Investigations

James Cameron will be speaking at an Ontario Bar Association program entitled Harassment Investigations: Pitfalls, Best Practices and New Approaches on Thursday, March 25, 2010.

James will be speaking from the perspective of an employee representative in harassment investigations, and will address issues including:

  • How do harassment policies fit with related legislation and regulations?
  • What are the procedural fairness requirements for harassment investigations?
  • How should privacy/confidentiality issues be dealt with in the investigation process?
  • What are the most common errors in an investigation, and what are the best practices?
  • What are the viable alternatives for fixing dysfunctional workplaces without conducting a major investigation, and when are they most effective?

Visit the OBA website for more information.