Author Archives: f5admin

Successive Periods of Total Disability

Attempting to return to work after receiving long-term disability insurance benefits can seem daunting. Many questions arise, but one we often hear is “what happens if I fail or get sick again?”  The short answer is that it depends on the amount of time that has passed since you returned work. You may start receiving long-term disability benefits again without having to wait.  Or in other words, without having to satisfy another “elimination period”.

Most long-term disability insurance policies have terms dealing with successive periods of total disability.  If you have returned to work and are unsuccessful or become ill again, then it will be important to review the terms of your policy with a disability benefits lawyer. The terms and time limits to qualify may vary from policy to policy.

Recurrent Disability

Long term disability insurance policies will often have certain requirements. Some will allow an employee to restart benefits if they become ill or are unable to work due to the same illness or cause within a specific time period.  For example, an employee with Fibromyalgia attempts to return to work following a one-year absence. A progressive return to work plan is established and the employee returns to work.  Unfortunately, she suffers from a flair up of her symptoms and her treating physician provides the insurance company with a medical report stating that the employee is unable to work.  Providing the recurrence took place within the time limit, this employee would qualify for an immediate reinstatement of benefits. Typically, the time limit for a recurrence of the same illness is 12 months.

Related Disability

Long term disability insurance policies will also often have provisions allowing benefits to be reinstated. This occurs if the employee becomes ill or is otherwise unable to work due to a related illness within a specific period of time, typically 6 months.  A related illness is one that results from the same cause as the initial illness or disability.  For example, an employee who develops mental health issues as a result of a physical disability. If they cannot work, this would be considered totally disabled due to a related disability.  An employee whose related illness renders them totally disabled would qualify for an immediate reinstatement of benefits. Of course, this is providing the recurrence took place within the time limit provided in the policy.

Unrelated Disability

In the event of Total Disability due to an unrelated cause or illness, Long term disability insurance policies also often provide for a reinstatement of benefits.  In this case the time limit is typically one month.  If this period has passed, then the employee will be required to satisfy the “elimination period” before having access to long term disability benefits.

Unfortunately, insurance companies may refuse to reinstate benefits even if the employee is within the time limit provided in the policy. They may argue that the fact that the employee was able to return to work temporarily demonstrates that they are not totally disabled.

Insurance companies may also refuse to reinstate benefits. This occurs when they do not believe the employee is experiencing a recurrence of the same illness or disability. It can also happen because they do not believe the new disability is related to the previous illness or disability.

Contact a disability benefits lawyer for assistance if your claim for reinstatement of long-term disability benefits is denied. We can often assist in resolving the issue with the insurance company. We can take action to obtain the necessary updated medical information or medical reports from the employee’s treating physicians or specialists.

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Legal advice cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

 

Arbitrator Finds Failure to Exhaust Search for Accommodation

In a recent decision, a labour arbitrator found that an employer had failed to exhaust the search for accommodation options for an employee with a permanent disability before attempting to terminate her employment. 

In Sodexo Canada Ltd v Canadian Union of Public Employees, Local 145, Arbitrator Randi Abramsky recognized that the search for accommodation for the grievor’s disability had been a long and difficult one. Nonetheless, she determined that the employer had not yet met the point of undue hardship in accommodating the grievor when it attempted to end her employment in mid-2018.

The Arbitrator found that the employer had not addressed two considerations which were fundamental to its duty to accommodate. First, the employer could not establish that the grievor was unable to perform a modified version of her former position using assistive equipment. Second, even if the grievor could not perform her own position, the Arbitrator found that the employer had not looked beyond the grievor’s original work location to attempt to find position she could perform at other worksites.

As a result, the Arbitrator concluded that the employer had breached its procedural duty to accommodate the grievor, contrary to the Human Rights Code. She therefore directed the employer to work with the grievor and the Union to explore these accommodation options, with the issue of damages and compensation for the breach to be determined once the accommodation process concluded.

The Union was represented in this case by Morgan Rowe of RavenLaw.

Anna Lichty Appointed to the Board of Directors for the Kiwanis Club of Ottawa

RavenLaw is pleased to announce that Anna Lichty has been appointed to the Board of Directors of the Kiwanis Club of Ottawa.

The Kiwanis Club of Ottawa is a not-for-profit organization and registered charity with members who effect positive change within the Ottawa community by volunteering their time and raising funds for programs that promote youth literacy and leadership, help individuals with special needs and assist those struggling in the community.

Anna is thrilled to be joining the Board of Directors. Anna is an active member of the Kiwanis Club of Ottawa and previously a member of the youth group Circle K of the University of Ottawa. She looks forward to continuing to assist the Kiwanis Club of Ottawa with their initiatives.

Long Term Disability Benefits Offsets – Does it Actually Reduce the Amount of Benefits? – Updated May 2021

What Are Long Term Disability Benefits Offsets?

long term disability benefits offsets

What Are Long Term Disability Income Offsets?

In the Long Term Disability Benefit context, offsets are other sources of employment or employment-like income. Offsets will be deducted from the amount of Long Term Disability benefit allowed to a claimant by an insurance company.

How Does LTD Coverage Work?

Insurers typically design their insurance Long Term Disability coverage contracts so they become ‘payers of last resort.’ This means that other sources of employment income are deducted, or offset from what the LTD insurer would otherwise pay in Long Term Disability benefits.

If you’re a unionized public servant, your LTD coverage is provided by SunLife and if you’re a public service executive, the insurer is Industrial Alliance. For public servants, SunLife and Industrial Alliance are the only alternatives. If you work in the private sector and your employer is providing LTD coverage, the offsets will likely be similar to those in the public service plan. If you’re insuring yourself, you can always negotiate fewer offsets, but they will cost you more money in premiums. If you don’t want any offset, the better alternative might be Critical Illness Insurance, which gets you a specific fixed payment for a specific injury or illness.

Here are some examples of how LTD coverage works:

  • Suppose you have LTD benefits which pay you $5,000 per month and you become eligible for a pension or a medical retirement which pays $3,000 per month. The insurer will see this new source of income and reduce the payment of $5000 to $2000 per month. The employee will still have a monthly income of $5,000, but it will consist of two cheques totalling $5,000, of which the insurer will only pay the difference between the pension and the original LTD benefit.
  • Suppose you are unable to work and you’re not able to provide the same level of financial support to your family. It’s likely that you think you’re going to get LTD benefits plus Canada Pension Plan Disability (CPPD) and your kids are going to be looked after, at least to some extent. If you are getting $1,000 a month from LTD, but your CPPD gives you $800 a month and there’s a $200 monthly child benefit for each of your three kids, that’s a total of $1,400 a month from sources outside your LTD payment. All that money, including the $200 for the children, are classified as offsets and will reduce your LTD to zero.
  • If you are in a car accident and you are paid damages for injuries, that would not be an offset. If you are paid damages for loss of income that would be an offset.
  • Savings or registered retirement savings plans (RRSPs), are not considered offsets and cannot be deducted from Long Term Disability benefits.

Can the Insurer Force You to Apply for Long Term Disability Offsets?

The answer will depend upon the language of the particular insurance policy. Frequently, the answer will be yes, particularly for such benefits as Canada Pension Plan Disability Benefits.  If the insured person fails to apply for the CPPD benefits, the LTD insurer will assume they have and will deduct the value of that benefit from the LTD, even if they do not apply.  

In the case of CPPD, that value is approximately $14,000 annually. There may even be an obligation to appeal from a negative ruling concerning CPPD.

For benefits such as pensions, if a person is in receipt of a pension, that amount will likely be considered an offset and deducted.  

If a person is not getting a pension, whether they must apply for a pension will usually depend on the language of the insurance policy.

Severance Pay

Severance is usually considered an offset and the insurance company will deduct 100% of it from LTD.  So, there can be substantial benefits to remaining an employee while you’re on LTD and it may not be necessary to terminate your employment. This is important because many people who lose their job and go on LTD prior to getting a severance package, think they will get to keep both. If maintaining your employment status is not possible, there are strategies that might be available that allow you to keep some or all of the severance package. 

The takeaway here is that you should not assume you are going to have multiple sources of income if you are on LTD because the insurance company will want most of it. The insurance companies say that without offsets, everyone’s premiums would be higher. This is true, but they will not give people the option of paying higher premiums in exchange for greater protection. The complexities of Long Term Disability are not something most people even think about. They get a job, they take the benefits they are offered and forget about it . . . until they are faced with dealing with long-term sickness or injury.

Is Long Term Disability Insurance Mandatory?

No, it is not a legal requirement but you would be unwise not to have it.

The biggest financial asset for most people is not their house but their ability to work. Simply put, if you and your family need income in order to live, you need Long Term Disability insurance, which will give you 50-70 percent of your former income. Without LTD, you are left with the Ontario Disability Support Programme at around $10,000-$12,000 a year and Canada Pension Place Disability which is around $14,000 a year. If you were making a reasonable income prior to your injury, going down to that level is not pleasant. 

Have questions? Reach out to our team of experienced Long Term Disability lawyers to learn more about LTD coverage.

David Yazbeck Appears Before Standing Committee on Industry, Science and Technology

On October 15, 2018, David Yazbeck appeared before the House of Commons Standing Committee on Industry, Science and Technology, acting on behalf of Copyright Visual Arts – Droits d’auteur Arts visuels (COVA-DAAV). Currently, the Committee is undertaking a review of the Copyright Act. David’s presentation related to recommendations by COVA-DAAV regarding improvements to the Act which would assist visual artists.

In particular, COVA-DAAV is recommending three changes to the Act:

  1. The inclusion of limitations on the educational fair dealing provisions so that the interests of visual artists and users are more balanced, and interference in collective licensing is removed;
  2. The removal of the 1988 cut-off date for the exhibition right so that artists with works created prior to that date would benefit from that right as it applies to those works; and
  3. The establishment of the artist’s resale right, a right which would require the payment of a royalty on transactions of secondary public art sales (i.e. where an artist’s work is sold subsequent to the first sale).

While all of these measures may seem minor, visual artists have among the lowest incomes in Canada and each measure would benefit visual artists immensely.

The full presentation can be viewed here.

 

Are my Disability Benefits Taxable? – Updated May 2021

Disability Benefits Taxable Implications

Disability Benefits Taxable Implications

With the month of April just around the corner, you may be getting ready to prepare and file your taxes for 2020. Many people ask us whether their Long Term Disability premiums are a taxable benefit in Canada. While there is no easy yes or no answer here, we have provided the important information you may need below. 

Do You Pay Income Tax on Disability Benefits in Canada? 

If you have been in receipt of disability benefits, you will need to understand the tax implications that apply to the disability benefit you have received. Different tax rules will apply depending on the type of benefit received, who paid the premiums for the benefit, and the total amount of income received by an individual in a given tax year.  

Below, you will find summary information about the tax implications when you have been in receipt of disability benefits. This information provides a general review and the implications for your specific situation will differ depending on your specific circumstances. For answers about your specific circumstances, you should consult with a lawyer specialized in this area of practice or a tax professional. 

Employment Insurance (EI) Sickness Benefits

The Employment Insurance program offers temporary financial assistance (up to a maximum of 15 weeks) to people unable to work because of sickness, injury or quarantine. These benefits are usually the first benefits received by an employee after they have exhausted their sick leave and they are unable to return to work because of continued injury or illness.

Employment Insurance benefits are taxable, which means that federal and provincial taxes will have been deducted from your EI payments prior to receipt. Depending on your total income for 2020, you may be required to repay a portion of EI benefits received when you file your taxes.   

If you were in receipt of EI benefits, you will receive a T4E, “Statement of Employment Insurance and Other Benefits” slip, which will indicate if you are required to repay a portion of the EI received. The T4E is issued by Service Canada. 

Short-Term Disability (STD) or Long-Term Disability (LTD) Benefits

Short-Term Disability (STD) benefits and/or Long-Term Disability (LTD) benefits provide some income protection when a person is unable to work due to an illness or injury. You may access STD and LTD coverage through purchasing personal insurance coverage and/or through accessing group insurance coverage. Group insurance coverage is generally accessed via an employee benefit plan. 

For more information on when and how to file a claim for Short-Term or Long-Term Disability benefits, please refer to our disability benefits page.

Whether tax is payable will depend on who has paid the premiums for the STD and/or LTD benefits. If any portion of the premiums for STD and/or LTD disability benefits were paid by your employer, the benefits are taxable. If all the premiums for your Short-Term or Long-Term Disability insurance were paid by you, the benefits are generally not taxed. 

Given the importance of the taxability of these benefits, employers, unions, and employees should all be concerned about who pays the premiums on these benefit plans.

If you are unsure as to who is paying the premiums for your disability plan, you can contact your insurance provider and they will notify you as to whether your benefits are taxable or not.

Canada Pension Plan Disability (CPPD) Benefits/ Québec Pension Plan (QPP) Disability Pension

The CPP disability benefit and QPP disability benefit are available to assist people who are unable to work in any capacity due to severe and prolonged disability. If you have qualified, and are receiving Canada Pension Plan Disability Benefits or Quebec Pension Plan Disability Pension, you should be aware that these benefits are taxable income. All the amounts received from CPP or QPP must be reported in your tax return. 

You would receive a T4A(P) “Statement of Canada Pension Plan Benefits” tax slip at the beginning of the year if you received benefits from the CPP or the QPP. The T4A(P) will indicate the amount of benefits you received in the previous year. If you received QPP benefits, you would also receive a RL-2 “Relevé 2: Retirement and annuity income” slip. 

Disability Tax Credit (DTC)

The CRA offers several tax credits to offset a disabled individual’s tax liability. A common tax credit accessed by people receiving CPP Disability Benefits is the Disability Tax Credit (DTC). This is a non-refundable tax credit that is available to persons who are experiencing severe and prolonged disability. 

The DTC tax credit assists to reduce the amount of income tax payable for persons with disabilities. Acknowledging that there are unavoidable additional expenses for persons with disabilities helps to provide greater tax equity. 

Accessing this tax credit requires a separate application, and not all persons in receipt of disability benefits will qualify. To apply, a specific form (Form T2201) must be completed by a medical practitioner and submitted to the CRA. The CRA then determines eligibility based on the information provided by the medical practitioner. 

A notice of determination will be provided to the applicant and will indicate which year(s) the applicant is eligible to claim the DTC. If the notice indicates that an applicant does not qualify, it will explain why. The notice may also include information about other programs that are available to individuals who qualify for the DTC. 

If a person would have been eligible for the DTC in prior years, but had not applied when they filed those taxes, they can seek a reassessment of the prior tax returns through the CRA.  

IMPORTANT LONG TERM DISABILITY TAX FORMS

Canada Pension Plan Disability (CPPD) Benefits/ Québec Pension Plan (QPP) Disability Pension

Disability Tax Credit (DTC)

Help for Persons with Low Income 

If your income is below qualifying thresholds, you may be able to access free assistance to complete your tax returns through a community organization. More information about free tax clinics to assist Canadians can be found by following this link. 

Consult one of our experienced Long-Term Disability lawyers at Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne and Yazbeck LLP if you have any questions.

David Yazbeck Appointed to the Board of Directors of COVA-DAAV

RavenLaw is pleased to announce that David Yazbeck has been appointed to the Board of Directors of Copyright Visual Arts – Droits d’outeur Arts visuels (COVA-DAAV). COVA-DAAV is the business operating name of CARCC, which is a copyright collective founded by Canadian Artists’ Representation – Le Front des Artistes Canadiens (CARFAC) in 1990 to assist artists in administering their copyrights. David is also a member of the Board of CARFAC and, as part of the governance structure for COVA-DAAV, CARFAC is entitled to appoint board members to the COVA-DAAV Board.

David is excited for this opportunity to continue his advocacy efforts on behalf of visual artists in Canada, particularly as it relates to protecting and promoting artists’ copyright in Canada and Quebec. Any interested artists from Canada and Quebec may affiliate with Copyright Visual Arts.

Julia Williams Presents at 2nd Annual OnCALL Conference

On September 29, 2018, Julia Williams was a panelist at the Ontario Region – Canadian Association of Labour Lawyers’ second annual conference (OnCALL2) in Kingston, Ontario. Julia participated in the “Ten Minute Labour Lawyer” panel, presenting on the recent arbitral decision in City of Kingston v CUPE 109. Julia would like to thank the organizers of OnCALL2 for inviting her to participate in this event.