Category Archives: Resources

Dayna Steinfeld Awarded the Advocates’ Society David Stockwood Memorial Prize

Dayna Steinfeld Awarded the Advocates’ Society David Stockwood Memorial Prize
Dayna Steinfeld is the 2022 recipient of The David Stockwood Memorial Prize. The prize is awarded to an advocacy-related written article, judged for its merit by a panel.

Dayna’s winning submission, “”Finding a Balance – Navigating the Advocacy Challenge for Union Side Labour Lawyers in Cases Involving Allegations of Member on Member Sexual Violence” examines the challenge for union-side lawyers of cross-examining a union member called as an employer witness in a case involving an allegation of sexual assault in the workplace. The article suggests that the union-side advocate can be guided by the legal principles of the law of consent to fulfil their role as an advocate for their client while balancing broader ethical obligations and being sensitive to the union’s equity-seeking goals and duties owed to all of its members.

Dayna’s article will be published in the Fall 2022 issue of The Advocates’ Journal.

Federal Court Recognizes Minister’s Obligation to Investigate Health and Safety Complaints

Federal Court Recognizes Minister’s Obligation to Investigate Health and Safety Complaints
In a recent decision, the Federal Court overturned a decision by a delegate of the Minister of Labour, which had refused to investigate the health and safety complaint of a Canada Border Service Agency employee.

The employee had filed a complaint with the Minister under the Canada Labour Code when CBSA had refused to appoint an impartial investigator to investigate his harassment concerns. CBSA had taken the position that it did not have to investigate the concerns because the employee was off-duty at the time of the alleged harassment, even though the incident took place within the workplace and the alleged harasser was the employee’s supervisor. When considering the employee’s Code complaint, the Minister of Labour’s Delegate refused to investigate the complaint, finding instead that the employee should file a human rights complaint because he was off-duty at the time of the incident.

In its decision, the Court found that the Minister’s Delegate did not have the option to refuse to investigate the employee’s complaint. Instead, the Court found that investigation was a mandatory obligation on the Delegate for this type of complaint, and the Delegate therefore committed an error by refusing to investigate.

In addition, the Court strongly questioned whether it was appropriate to deny the employee harassment protections under the Code because he was off-duty at the time of the incident. As the Court stated:

“While the Applicant was in fact off-duty when the incident occurred… it remains that the Applicant was still in his place of work and the agent of the alleged harassment and violence was the Applicant’s supervisor. Therefore, it becomes difficult to disregard the employee-employer connection in this incident, and the fact that the effects of the incident are evidently different for the Applicant than for a regular traveller who is not employed by the CBSA. Since the place, the tone, and the circumstances of the incident are indicative of the existence of a nexus between the incident of violence and the work place, the issue becomes whether or not the incident itself constitutes harassment and violence. The Respondent’s submissions seem to suggest that if an employee acts within the requirements of their job, as provided for by their work policy or statute, their actions against an off-duty employee while in the place of work cannot constitute harassment or work place violence. I agree with the Applicant that this could set a concerning precedent…”

Based on its analysis, the Court set aside the Minister’s Delegate’s decision and referred the matter back for a new decision.

The Applicant was represented by Morgan Rowe of RavenLaw.

RavenLaw Presents at Labour Law Conference

RavenLaw Presents at Labour Law Conference

During the week of June 20, 2022, RavenLaw presented as part of multiple panels during the Canadian Association of Labour Lawyers’ annual conference.

On June 24, 2022, Sean McGee presented as part of a panel exploring the opportunities and challenges of remote work post-COVID. In the afternoon, Wassim Garzouzi moderated a panel with two guest speakers from the United States, which discussed unionizing workplaces like Amazon and the need to reform labour laws.

On June 25, 2022, Amarkai Laryea presented on a panel addressing the impacts that current grievance arbitration models have on racialized workers and ways to practice labour law in an actively anti-racist manner.

Dayna Steinfeld to Present on Tips for Mediations, Informal Proceedings in Labour and Employment Law

Dayna Steinfeld to Present on Tips for Mediations, Informal Proceedings in Labour and Employment Law

On May 9, 2022, Dayna Steinfeld will be presenting on a panel hosted by the Manitoba Bar Association’s Alternative Dispute Resolution, Labour & Employment Law, and Legal Research sections. Dayna will discuss legal research and practice tips for mediations and informal proceedings in labour and employment law.

For more information or to register for this lunch-hour session, please visit the MBA website.

RavenLaw Hosts Lunch ‘N’ Learn for Union Representatives

RavenLaw Hosts Lunch ‘N’ Learn for Union Representatives

Join Wassim Garzouzi, Jessica Greenwood, and Dayna Steinfeld on June 20, 2022 from 12:00 – 1:00 EDT for a virtual discussion on the Supreme Court’s decision in Northern Regional Health Authority v Horrocks.

Wassim, Jessica, and Dayna will review the decision, the potential patchwork results of the decision across the country, and will answer audience questions about how the decision will impact union representatives. Topics will include: What is the expected impact of this decision across Canada? What do unions need to know about the decision for their representation of members in health care sectors and beyond? What practical implications does Horrocks have for unions, given the Supreme Court’s conclusion that labour arbitrators have exclusive jurisdiction over issues arising under the collective agreement, including human rights complaints, unless there is clear legislative intent to the contrary? Can union members pursue individual human rights complaints and, if not, what does the duty of fair representation require from unions?

The Lunch ‘N’ Learn is free, but pre-registration is required. Please contact bkone@ravenlaw.com to register and request the Zoom link.

RavenLaw Welcomes New Partners!

RavenLaw is pleased to welcome Michael Fisher, Raphaëlle Laframboise-Carignan, Amanda Montague-Reinholdt, and Morgan Rowe into the partnership, effective January 1, 2022.

Michael, Raphaëlle, Amanda and Morgan have worked with RavenLaw for many years and have made significant contributions to the firm. We thank them for their important work in advancing union and worker rights, and congratulate them on becoming partners.

Ontario Divisional Court Directs WSIAT to Grant Benefits

In a significant victory, the Ontario Divisional Court recently set aside a Workplace Safety Insurance Appeals Tribunal (“WSIAT”) decision and directed the WSIAT to grant benefits to the injured worker.

The Worker was injured on the job and, as a result, was no longer able to work. However, he was denied benefits by the Workplace Safety Insurance Board (“WSIB”) and the WSIAT because he waited several weeks after the accident before seeking medical care. The WSIAT found that the Worker had not proven that the workplace accident significantly contributed to his injury.

At the Divisional Court, the Worker argued that it was unreasonable for the WSIAT to discount uncontradicted medical evidence and to rely so heavily on his delay in seeking treatment. The Court agreed, finding that the WSIAT’s decision suffered “from serious logical flaws” which resulted in an “outcome [that was] unreasonable, based on the record.” It therefore set the WSIAT’s decision aside.

The Court then went one step further and held that the delay in resolving the Worker’s claim was a serious concern. The accident occurred in 2005, which meant that the Worker had been waiting over 15 years for benefits. Given the amount of time that had elapsed since the injury and the clear evidentiary record, the Court did not send the file back to the WSIAT for reconsideration. Instead, it found that the Worker was entitled to benefits for the injury. It referred the matter back to the WSIAT to assess his claim.

This is an important win for workers who are faced with unreasonable decisions from statutory tribunals such as the WSIAT. It affirms that the Divisional Court has the option, in certain cases, to direct the outcome instead of sending the issue back to the tribunal for reconsideration.

The Worker was represented by Julia Williams, Wassim Garzouzi, and Anna Rotman.

James Cameron Interviewed on Concussion Central Podcast

James Cameron Interviewed on Concussion Central Podcast
James Cameron recently gave a featured interview on Concussion Central’s podcast. James and host David McGuffin discussed return to work strategies following a concussion and how to talk to your employer about concussion issues and accommodation in the workplace.
Listen to a preview from James’ interview here, or access the full episode on the podcast website or from your favourite podcast platform.