Category Archives: Resources

Federal Court Quashes Minister’s Decision on Work Refusal

In a recent decision, the Federal Court quashed a decision on behalf of the Minister of Labour, in which the Minister had refused to investigate the work refusal of a federal public service employee.

The Applicant employee had notified her employer that she was refusing to work for health and safety reasons in February 2015. On May 13, 2015, the Labour Affairs Officer assigned to the Applicant’s case completed a memorandum recommending a finding of dangerous work. Nonetheless, on July 13, 2015, the Applicant was advised that the Minister was declining to investigate her work refusal on the basis that her concerns were better addressed through a grievance.

In its January 31, 2017 decision, the Federal Court held that the Minister’s decision was unreasonable. The Court found that the decision-maker had offered no transparent or justifiable explanation for rejecting the Labour Affairs Officer’s recommendation or for concluding that the grievance process was a more appropriate way to address the Applicant’s concerns.

In reaching its conclusion, the Court also highlighted the importance of ensuring that refusals of unsafe work are dealt with in a timely manner, through the specialized process established under the Canada Labour Code, noting that it found the Applicant’s submissions on these points persuasive.

The Applicant was represented in this application by Andrew Raven and Morgan Rowe of RavenLaw.

 

RavenLaw Supports Annual LEAF Persons Day Breakfast

RavenLaw was proud to support the Annual Ottawa Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (“LEAF”) Persons Day Breakfast. This year’s breakfast focused on the Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women in Canada.

LEAF is a charitable non-profit organization that works to advance the equality rights of women and girls in Canada. The annual fundraising breakfast commemorates the Persons Case – the October 18, 1929 decision of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council that ruled that women were to be considered persons under the law and should be eligible to sit in the Canadian Senate. Proceeds from the Persons Day breakfast contribute to LEAF’s litigation efforts, and help to sustain our equality education programs such as LEAF at Work, the Only Yes Means Yes Campaign, and the Reproductive Justice Campaign.

 

Federal Court Overturns Classification Decision for a Second Time

In a recent court decision, the Federal Court overturned the decision of the Canada Border Service Agency to reject the classification grievances of over 45 management employees. The Court found that CBSA’s decision was unreasonable because it failed to consider portions of the employees’ job description which strongly supported their request for an upward reclassification. Furthermore, the Court found that CBSA had not explained its reasons for reaching a decision that appeared contrary to the evidence.

This is the second time these employees have been successful in overturning CBSA’s decision to reject their grievances. The previous decision of the Federal Court was rendered on July 24, 2014.

The employees were represented in both cases by Andrew Raven and Morgan Rowe of Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck LLP.

Wassim Garzouzi Elected as Vice-President for the Canadian Association of Labour Lawyers

Wassim Garzouzi was elected as Vice-President (Ontario) for the Canadian Association of Labour Lawyers at CALL’s annual conference in St. John’s, Newfoundland from June 2 to 5, 2016. Wassim is thankful for the support he received and looks forward to representing CALL’s Ontario members.

CALL’s mission is to connect union-side labour lawyers across Canada and to advocate for the legal interests of Canadian workers and labour organizations before provincial and federal governments, labour boards, and all levels of court.

Wassim Garzouzi Presented on Stopping Sexual Harassment

On June 16, 2016, Wassim Garzouzi spoke as part of Lancaster House’s audio conference on Stopping Sexual Harassers Cold: Optimal practices for complaint procedures, investigations, and survivor support. The program addressed how to identify sexual harassment, best practices for investigating complaints, and internal procedures and outside resources that can help fractured workplaces. The audio conference also covered the factors that arbitrators and human rights tribunals consider when assessing damage awards for harassment.

 

Dismissed employee receives punitive damages award

In a recent decision, the Superior Court of Ontario awarded a dismissed employee punitive damages because of the employer’s conduct in terminating the employee. This judgment sends a clear message to employers that mistreatment of employees upon termination will not be accepted, and can result in additional liability.

Tom Morison’s employment was terminated after approximately 8 years. Mr. Morison brought a claim for wrongful dismissal. In addition to his claim for reasonable notice, he also alleged that the employer had violated its duty of good faith in the termination, including:

  • Notwithstanding excellent performance, the employer alleged that Mr. Morison had been terminated for cause, without any meaningful evidence to support its position.
  • The employer delayed issuing a Record of Employment for several months after the termination, preventing Mr. Morison from accessing employment insurance.
  • The employer failed to pay Mr. Morison the minimum amounts owed to him under the Employment Standards Act (“ESA”) until three years after the termination.

In his judgment, Justice Roger agreed that this conduct warranted an award of punitive damages. Justice Roger concluded that such conduct was “reprehensible”. He added that the employer’s actions “exceeds what might be considered as ill-advised. The allegations of cause, made with no reasonable basis, and the significantly delayed payment of statutory amounts were intentional and financially impacted the plaintiff. These actions of the defendant were designed to financially benefit the defendant and the defendant had knowledge of the plaintiff’s precarious financial position. Such a conduct is ‘malicious, oppressive and high-handed’ and ‘a marked departure from ordinary standards of decent behaviour’.”

Justice Roger determined that an award of $50,000 in punitive damages was appropriate in the circumstances.

Important message sent to employers

This decision sets an important precedent and will hopefully give pause to employers who try to exert financial pressure on dismissed employees. Unfortunately, some employers resort to tactics such as delaying payment of ESA notice and severance, or raising allegations of just cause without any reasonable grounds, in an attempt to secure a quicker and less expensive settlement of the termination.

These strategies are reprehensible, and received a well-deserved rebuke from the Court in this judgment. Recently terminated employees are vulnerable and are often prepared to waive their rights for an immediate payout, even if the amount is below what is reasonable or required by law. By delaying payment of the ESA minimums, employers add additional pressure on employees to accept less than desirable settlement agreements. This judgment gives employees and their advocates greater power to defend against these tactics: the prospect of a significant award of punitive damages will hopefully deter other employers from acting in this manner in the future.

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]