Category Archives: Resources

Callow v Zollinger and Good Faith Obligations in Employment Law

In a recent contract case, Callow v Zollinger, 2020 SCC 45, the Supreme Court confirmed that damages can flow from a contractual breach of good faith when one party knowingly misleads the other. Good faith between parties is an unwritten obligation found in contracts. The exact nature of that obligation may vary some, depending on the type of contract. 

Now, the Court has clarified the legal obligation to perform a contract in good faith includes a responsibility to avoid misleading the other party. This may have a significant effect on employment contracts, as employees are entitled to rely on what an employer says it will do, including representations made beyond the precise wording of the contract. 

Contractual Obligations Must be Performed in Good Faith 

Callow v Zollinger involved a contract between a group of condominiums, represented by property manager Mr. Zollinger, and a lawn and winter maintenance company, represented by Mr. Callow. The contract was terminated with ten days’ notice, allowed by the contract’s wording. However, Mr. Zollinger knew the condominiums had decided to terminate the winter maintenance contract months prior, and yet he did not inform Mr. Callow and allowed him to perform extra work during the summer months.

The Court found Mr. Zollinger breached the good faith obligation by failing to disclose that the contract would end before the winter. Mr. Zollinger knew Mr. Callow was completing the extra work because Mr. Callow thought the contract would continue through the winter, as it had in years past. Additionally, because Mr. Callow did not know the contract was ending, he, therefore, could not seek out other winter maintenance work until the last minute which was detrimental to his business. The condominiums benefitted from Mr. Callow’s extra work during the summer months knowing that the work was done on the basis the contract would continue.

There are two main takeaways: (1) misleading actions can attract monetary damages in court and (2) the contract’s specific wording does not end the parties’ obligations—breaches can occur when one party’s actions are misleading, even if allowed within the wording of the contract.

What Does the Duty of Good Faith Mean for Employment Cases?

Courts have consistently recognized that employers have unique power and control over their employees, particularly compared to other contractual relationships. The employer’s higher degree of control over employees requires a higher degree of honesty. 

Courts have already imposed good faith obligations specifically on employers, such as the requirement to act in good faith when dismissing employees. When terminating an employee, employers must avoid “being untruthful, misleading or unduly insensitive” and instead be “candid, reasonable, honest, and forthright.” 

Given the reasoning in Callow, the Court seems to expand this responsibility by holding there is a contractual responsibility to correct the other party’s mistaken impressions and avoid knowingly misleading statements or lying by omission.

In the employment context, an employer’s misleading statements or promises could be detrimental to employees in a wide variety of situations including pay increases, promotions, scheduling changes, the choice of whether and how to provide work, and term contract renewal. Additionally, independent contractors can expect greater protections after Callow, even though they do not have employee status, since the duty of honest performance applies to all contracts.

If your employer misled you or lied to you about your employment conditions, even if they followed their obligations as written under the contract, an employment lawyer can advise you about whether your employer breached their contractual obligation of good faith, giving rise to a claim for damages. 

How to Submit a Long-Term Disability Claim

A long-term disability (LTD) claim is essential for those unable to work due to a debilitating medical condition or injury. If you cannot work because of a medical condition or injury, it may be possible to secure LTD benefits. Today, let’s examine how to submit a long-term disability claim in more detail. In addition, we’ll cover what happens if you are denied including next steps.

Make the Most of the Elimination Period

Among your responsibilities is the need for a firm understanding of your elimination period. This is otherwise known as the waiting period – the amount of time you must be disabled for prior to applying. Submitting your claim too early is sometimes a risk, as you may be turned down for not proving beyond a reasonable doubt your inability to work. Most of the time, however, early applicants will simply be required to wait. While waiting for the elimination period to end, you should instead gather as much medical documentation in support of your claim as possible. We also recommend consulting your employer’s policy booklet to ensure all their terms and conditions are met. The more thorough and complete your claim and supporting documentation is, the better the chances you’ll have of getting accepted – all while reducing the risk of delays.

The “Big Three”

When submitting a long-term disability claim, there are normally three important statements you must include with it. Sometimes only two are needed – one from yourself and a doctor – but this depends on the employer in question. The so-called “big three” are as follows:

Employee Statement

Your first-hand statement needs to be clear and concise about your physical and/or mental limitations and/or restrictions. For instance, if you are diagnosed with depression, list the specific conditions and symptoms that prevent you from working. You should also detail why you cannot work in your field of expertise – do not hold back on any critical factors and remain as accurate as possible. And don’t worry if you run out of room – a second sheet can be attached without voiding your application. 

Employer Statement

In most cases, the employer in question must provide equally clear, concise and thorough documentation of your situation. This usually includes a complete list of the duties within your role, and whether it would be feasible to alter your role. 

Practitioner (Doctor) Statement

We’ve noticed that doctor’s statements can often be incomplete or difficult to interpret. That’s why our legal team is happy to resolve any conflicts by acting as a liaison between you and your doctor prior to submitting your claim. Doctors may have busier jobs than ever, but they still must provide ample detail on your symptoms, diagnosis, recommended treatments and whether you’ve undertaken them, and why you cannot perform your duties. All relevant medical documentation – treatment programs, visitation records and otherwise – must be attached with this statement. This statement is the most heavily scrutinized by claim analyzers for accuracy and legitimacy. Remember, LTD insurers are known to even monitor social media behaviour by the applicant to verify their honesty.

What if I’m Turned Down?

Sometimes a rejection can be remedied by providing more complete information or addressing any red flags. The clearer the picture for the individual analyzing the claim, the better. Usually, you won’t be denied and instead will receive a request for more medical evidence. Alternatively, if you aren’t following treatment recommendations by your doctor you may be denied LTD benefits. We’ve covered the main reasons why you would be denied in this blog post – give it a read to learn more. 

Need Help with Your LTD Claim, ASAP? Contact RavenLaw Today!

At RavenLaw, our legal professionals can help you with unbiased, expert feedback on your LTD application, statements and attached documentation. If anything is unclear, missing or otherwise, we can work with you on resolving any grey areas. Reach out to us to get started!

Federal Court of Appeal Quashes Classification Decision for Third Time

In a recent court decision, the Federal Court of Appeal overturned the decision of the Canada Border Service Agency to reject the classification grievances of over 45 management employees.

The Court found that CBSA’s decision was unreasonable because it refused to reclassify the managers’ position on the basis that it did not perform certain decision-making responsibilities, when this was not actually a requirement of the classification rules or guidelines. Furthermore, the Court found that CBSA had misapprehended and failed to identify any mistake in the Classification Grievance Committee report which had recommended upwardly reclassifying the managers’ position.

This is the third time these employees have been successful in overturning CBSA’s decision to reject their grievances. Recognizing the exceptional nature of these circumstances, the Court of Appeal concluded that it would not be appropriate to return the decision to CBSA for redetermination a fourth time.

As the Court stated: “This Court’s intervention rests on its core strength which is determining if the justification for a decision is reasonable. Having found that the Deputy Head’s rejection of the Committee’s recommendation was unreasonable, and considering that in three attempts to justify his conclusion, the Deputy Head has been unable to formulate a rationale which withstands review on a deferential standard, this Court is not overreaching in requiring the Minister to accept an expert recommendation that he is unable to justify rejecting.”

The Court therefore ordered CBSA to render a new decision, consistent with the recommendation of the Classification Grievance Committee. This should bring to a close more than a decade of litigation that the Appellants have had to pursue to have their classification grievances appropriately addressed by their employer.

The Appellants were represented by Andrew Raven and Morgan Rowe of RavenLaw.

Bargaining in a COVID Economy. Get Informed – It’s Your Right

For unions, another round of negotiations has often meant getting back into a familiar pattern: deliver notice to bargain, prepare proposals, have a series of sometimes constructive, sometimes frustrating discussions across the bargaining table, perhaps resort to strike or face a lockout, then arrive at a collective agreement.

We are living in a different world.  Do not assume same-old is the same old.

A union may have a right to a range of information that is relevant to collective bargaining. Unions have a right to receive information about changes an employer is considering that may have a major impact on the bargaining unit.  That is particularly true in response to certain employer positions like a declaration of an inability to pay. They have that right even if they don’t ask, as the obligation to disclose is part of the duty to bargain in good faith.  If they ask, the obligation is probably even more extensive. You can look at a decision called PSAC v. Forintek Canada Corp. for details about how the Ontario Labour Relations Board applied this principle several decades ago.  It is still good law.

Employers may be thinking about a variety of options as COVID-19 remains one of the central features of the economy – from local markets to international trade.  A Union and its members are entitled to know what decisions have been made and what decisions are being considered. To be in the best position to prepare demands, to negotiate for appropriate contract terms and to speak with members about whether a tentative collective agreement is reasonable, it is more important than ever to create a comprehensive request for information and disclosure.

Each request will be different and will depend on the sector of the economy, local conditions, and the relationship between the Union and the employer.  Whatever the circumstances, no union should go into bargaining (or if already there, sign a tentative agreement) without making the request.

The information may be significant, or there may not be much.  It may be that the employer is forthcoming, or it may be necessary to extract it like you were doing dentistry.  In any event, it is much better to have made the request than to be surprised two months after signing the agreement with a reorganization, or a series of layoffs, or some other change that had been in the works for a considerable period of time.

This is one of the obligations the parties have in bargaining. It is more important than ever to make sure the other side lives up to its obligations.

Supreme Court Finds RCMP Pension Scheme Discriminates Against Women

On October 16, 2020, the Supreme Court of Canada upheld a Charter challenge to portions of the RCMP pension plan, which had been applied to prevent employees from buying back periods of service during which they had temporarily reduced hours of work for childcare reasons.

In its decision, the majority of the Supreme Court concluded that the pension law had a disproportionate, negative impact on women due to their sex. Particularly, the majority noted that the evidence demonstrated both that the Appellants themselves had been negatively impacted by the pension scheme due to childcare responsibilities and that, more broadly, women as a group face disadvantages related to balancing work and childcare obligations. The majority also accepted that the specific negative impact in this case perpetuated historical gender biases in pension plans. The majority concluded that the pension law therefore breached the equality rights of women, contrary to section 15 of the Charter.

As the Government could not provide a pressing or substantial reason to justify the negative impact on women, the Court directed the Government to design remedial measures to address the negative impacts on the pensions of the Appellants and others in the same position.

Andrew Astritis and Morgan Rowe from RavenLaw appeared on behalf of the intervener, the Public Service Alliance of Canada, to support the Appellants in their arguments that the pension law discriminates against women and other parents because of their childcare obligations.

Is there recourse for COVID-19 discrimination?

Ravenlaw gratefully acknowledges the contribution of this post by articling student Simcha Walfish.

As the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) has noted, the “COVID-19 pandemic has sparked a rise in stigma and discrimination against people who have the virus; people from countries where the virus originated or are considered hot zones; people who have travelled recently; or even those who it is believed have come in contact with someone who has the virus.”

When people face discrimination because of this stigma, what recourse can they hope for in Ontario’s human rights law? The Ontario Human Rights Commission has taken the position that the “Code ground of disability is engaged in relation to COVID-19, as it covers medical conditions or perceived medical conditions that carry significant social stigma.” This means that an employer who fires an employee because the employee is diagnosed with COVID-19 may be held responsible for human rights violations. Further, under the Code, discrimination based on perception of disability is prohibited. So, if an employer believes the employee may have COVID-19, they may also be held responsible for human rights violations.

These grounds for discrimination will hold true for all areas covered by the Code. For example, a landlord that evicts a tenant because the tenant has, or is perceived to have, COVID-19 could be found liable for the discrimination.

In a case working its way through the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal, a harm reduction worker in the Vancouver Downtown Eastside and Surrey was evicted due to her landlord’s concern that she had been exposed to COVID-19 because of her work. The landlord argued that her claim should be dismissed because COVID-19 is not a physical disability under the Code and the claim therefore had no prospect of success.

The Tribunal refused to dismiss the complaint because the stigma of COVID-19 is such that even being perceived to have it should be protected under the ground of physical disability. The Tribunal reasoned that “this aspect of the complaint is about the alleged stigma that attaches to Covid-19, quite apart from the virus’ effects on a person who has it. In my view, the issue raised by this aspect of the complaint falls squarely within the ambit of perceived physical disability.”

Once a complainant establishes that they have been the subject of discrimination due to having, or being perceived to have, COVID-19, the burden will shift to respondents to justify the conduct for legitimate health and safety reasons and to show why they could not accommodate the complainant. General concerns about the virus will not be enough to justify discrimination. In the BC case, the Tribunal found the landlord’s arguments regarding his “genuine worries” about health to be insufficient without detailed information about his specific vulnerabilities, his understanding about COVID-19 at the time, his genuine concerns, what information he sought from the tenant, and what options he considered before eviction.

It remains to be seen how much latitude human rights tribunals will grant those who discriminate based on “genuine worries” about the virus. But, if the case from BC is any indication, those who have faced discrimination based on COVID-19 stigma need not assume that concerns related to the virus will always prevail over the right to be free from discrimination.

If you have questions or concerns about the implications of COVID-19 on your employment, please call 613-567-2901 or email info@ravenlaw.com. If you are a member of a union, please contact them directly for assistance in dealing with your workplace issue.

 

Bargaining Unit Positions May Be Tied to Work Location, Trigger Job Posting and Seniority Rights

In a recent grievance decision between the Limestone District School Board and CUPE Local 1480, Arbitrator Jesse Nyman found that changing a bargaining unit member’s work location may eliminate a position and create a vacancy, triggering the mandatory posting provisions of a collective agreement.

In 2013, the Employer decided to close two of its secondary schools in Kingston, Ontario and to construct a new secondary school. The grievance began when the Employer announced its intention to unilaterally transfer staff from one of the old schools to the new school when it opened.

At arbitration, the Union argued that, when an old school closes, the positions at that school cease to exist and when the new school opens, vacancies will be created that must be posted and filled in accordance with the posting and seniority provisions of the parties’ collective agreements. The Employer defended its intention to simply transfer staff from one school to another by arguing that there were no vacancies created, only a change in work location, and therefore no provisions of the collective agreements applied.

In his decision, the Arbitrator agreed with the Union’s position that the shutting down of the old schools and opening of the new school was a “school closure” within the meaning of the collective agreement. The Arbitrator also accepted the Union’s argument that the collective agreements prohibited the Employer from unilaterally transferring employees from one work location to another when a school closes. Rather, the posting provisions must be applied. The Arbitrator found that this interpretation was supported by the plain language of the agreements and the parties’ past practice regarding school-to-school transfers. The grievance was therefore allowed and the Board was ordered to post the new positions in accordance with the terms of the collective agreements.

This win for the Union highlights that a change of work location, depending on the language of the collective agreement, may trigger a vacancy that requires a position to be posted. This reinforces the importance of seniority rights for workers, which are almost always a key determinant in filling vacant positions.

The Union was represented by Julia Williams of RavenLaw.