Category Archives: News

Canadian Human Rights Commission decision on medicinal marijuana case overturned for a second time

For the second time, a decision of the Canadian Human Rights Commission to dismiss a complaint regarding discrimination related to medicinal marijuana has been set aside by the courts. In McIlvenna v Bank of Nova Scotia, the Federal Court found that the Commission breached its duty of fairness and ignored obviously crucial evidence supporting a complaint that Scotiabank had called in a mortgage because of the presence of medicinal marijuana on the mortgaged property.

Background

The Applicant, Robert McIlvenna, had a mortgage with the Bank, and had applied for an additional line of credit to perform renovations on the mortgaged house, which was occupied by his son and daughter-in-law. The Bank refused the line of credit and called in Mr. McIlvenna’s mortgage, and he alleged the Bank took this action because it had learned that medicinal marijuana was being grown in the home under a Health Canada license. The Bank maintained that the reason for its actions was a violation of the terms of the mortgage.

The Canadian Human Rights Commission initially rejected the complaint without an investigation. That decision was overturned by the Federal Court of Appeal, which found it unreasonable for the Commission to refuse to investigate, when there was a live factual dispute between the parties as to whether the Bank made its decision on discriminatory grounds. (See the Federal Court of Appeal’s decision here.)

The complaint was returned to the Commission for investigation. Following its investigation, the Commission again dismissed the complaint, finding that further inquiry into the complaint was not warranted. Mr. McIlvenna again sought judicial review of the decision in Federal Court. Among his arguments, he raised the fact that there were internal Bank emails in the Commission’s investigation file, which clearly supported the McIlvennas’ allegation that the mortgage was called in because of the presence of medicinal marijuana.

Judgment of the Federal Court 

In his judgment, dated July 19, 2017, Justice Boswell of the Federal Court allowed the Application for judicial review. He found that the Commission failed to investigate obviously crucial evidence before it—specifically, the internal Bank emails. The Court held:

“The content of these two emails, in particular the email sent July 15, 2010, is obviously crucial evidence given the relevant allegations in the Applicant’s human rights complaint and the contradictory statements by the Applicant and his son. A reasonable person would agree that this evidence was crucial because it lends credence to the Applicant’s position that his son’s growing of medical marijuana may have been a factor in the Bank’s decision to call in the mortgage. Although the July 15, 2010 email is certainly not conclusive of exactly what was said during the July 15th meeting, at the very least it tends to corroborate the Applicant’s claim that Ms. Joliat discussed the Bank’s policy on grow-ops during their meeting and is crucial in determining the merits of the Applicant’s claim.”

Justice Boswell found that the Investigator “glossed over this evidence”, and failed to investigate the Bank’s policy on marijuana “grow-ops” in determining whether the Bank had a reasonable, non-discriminatory explanation for calling in the mortgage. The Court went on to find the ultimate decision unreasonable, because the Commission’s analysis “essentially ignores the evidence contained in Ms. Joliat’s two emails”, despite the fact that these emails supported the McIlvennas’ version of events. The complaint was referred back to the Commission for re-determination and, if necessary, further investigation.

The Applicant was represented in the Federal Court by Andrew Astritis and Amanda Montague-Reinholdt of RavenLaw.

 

RavenLaw Supports the Workers’ Bowl

On November 4, 2017, RavenLaw participated in the 6th annual Workers’ Bowl, an annual fundraiser in Toronto for the Workers’ Action Centre, a worker-based organization that advocates for fair working conditions for vulnerable workers. The Workers’ Action Centre has a Workers’ Rights Info Line that workers can call for support, offers workshops on workers’ rights and is part of the campaign to raise the minimum wage to $15.

The bowling tournament is hosted by the Ontario Employment Education & Research Centre (OEERC), a non-profit that works with community partners such as the Workers’ Action Centre to educate workers on their rights and provide supports to workers whose rights have been violated.

This is the second year that the RavenLaw team – Wassim Garzouzi, Morgan Rowe, Anna Lichty, and Marlee Olson – has joined bowlers from unions and union-side labour firms, among other supporters, to help raise funds for these important initiatives.

 

You Can’t Take It With You: Good Faith and Fiduciary Duties of Departing Employees

In a recent decision, the Ontario Superior Court affirmed that departing employees can owe a duty of good faith and a fiduciary duty to their former employer, and a violation of those duties can give rise to a significant damages award. This decision marks an important reminder to employees regarding their obligations when leaving their employment.

Background

The Prim8 Group Inc. is a communications agency who hired Richard Tisi, initially on a contract basis and then as a one-third shareholder, director and officer of the agency, to develop websites for Prim8 clients. Tisi, together with an employee, Ian MacArthur, developed customized management software for Prim8.

A dispute arose between Tisi and Prim8, and Tisi left his employment. When he left, he took his computer equipment, including access to the customized management software. Shortly thereafter, MacArthur also left Prim 8, and he and Tisi began working on a competing business. Prim8 sued for inducement to breach contract, as well as conversion and breach of fiduciary duty.

Judgment of the Ontario Superior Court

In The Prim8 Group Inc. v. Tisi and MacArthur 2016 ONSC 5662, Prim8 was successful in its action against Tisi and MacArthur. The Court found that Prim8 had established its claims for breach of duty, conversion and inducing breach of contract, and awarded approximately $100,000 in damages, together with costs, against the Defendants.

The Court found that “employees owe their employers a general duty of good faith and loyalty (or fidelity) as an implied term of their employment contract.” The Court further held that, as a senior officers of the corporation, Tisi owed a fiduciary duty of “loyalty, good faith and avoidance of conflict of duty and self-interest.” The Court held that Tisi had breached his fiduciary duty in taking the computer equipment and customized management software assets of Prim8, and converting them to his own use. The Court also found that Tisi actively impeded Prim8’s ability to make changes to its client websites. The Court assessed damages for the replacement of the assets taken by Tisi, together with damages for lost billings to Prim8’s former clients.

Both Tisi and MacArthur were also held liable for a failure to give proper notice of their departure. Tisi was also found to have induced MacArthur to breach his contract with Prim8.

Discussion

Tisi and MacArthur found themselves in a position that no employee wants or expects to be in—having moved on to new employment, they were taken to court by their former employer because of breaches of their obligations upon departure. This case stands as an important reminder to employees, particularly senior employees, that their duties to their employer do not necessarily end at the moment they tender their resignation. All employees should seek legal advice concerning notice and fiduciary obligations to their former employers, if they are planning to leave their employment.

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

Michael Fisher Presented at Human Rights and Labour Law Conference

On November 8, 2017, Michael Fisher spoke as part of the panel “Fitness to Work: Ensuring a Safe Work Environment in an Era of Marijuana, Opioids, and Other Drugs,” at Lancaster House’s Human Rights and Labour Law Conference in Ottawa. The panel focused on the common misperceptions on the use of medical marijuana and other drugs, impairment testing in safety sensitive workplaces, an employee’s duty to disclose their use of medical marijuana and other prescription drugs, and balancing accommodation and safety obligations.

Jacob Saltiel Judges First-Year Law Students Moot at U of O

On November 5, 2016, Jacob Saltiel participated as a judge in the University of Ottawa Law’s moot court competition for first-year students. Jacob judged two groups of students who presented arguments based on the Ontario Court of Appeal’s decision in Spence v BMO Trust Company. Jacob provided commentary and guidance to the impressive participants on their oral advocacy and presentation.

 

David Yazbeck Appointed to Queen’s Centre for Law in the Contemporary Workplace Advisory Committee

David Yazbeck has recently been appointed as a member of the Advisory Committee for the Queen’s Centre for Law in the Contemporary Workplace. This committee is composed of leaders in the field of workplace law. It is a tremendous resource for the Centre, providing advice on emerging issues, on research and conference activity and linking the Centre and its work to diverse professional communities with an interest in workplace law. Launched in 2010, the mission of the Centre is to advance law and policy in the contemporary workplace. Its vision is to be a leading force for innovation and law, policy and dialogue in the contemporary workplace.

Amanda Montague-Reinholdt Elected to Board of Magnetic North Theatre Festival

Amanda Montague-Reinholdt has been elected to the Board of Directors for the Magnetic North Theatre Festival. Amanda has also been elected to serve as Secretary on the Board’s Executive Committee.

Magnetic North is Canada’s only national theatre festival, showcasing the very best of contemporary Canadian theatre. It has its home base in Ottawa, which hosts the festival every second year. The festival also has a unique travelling mandate, hosting the festival in a different community across Canada in alternate years, including the incredibly successful 2016 festival in Whitehorse. The next festival will take place in Ottawa in June 2017, coinciding with the celebrations of Canada’s 150th anniversary.

Congratulations to Megan Fultz and Emily Cumbaa, the 2017 Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck Human Rights/Social Justice Interns

The partners of Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck are pleased to announce the selection of the successful 2017 Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck Human Rights/Social Justice Internship candidates, Megan Fultz and Emily Cumbaa. Both Megan and Emily are in the second year of their studies at the University of Ottawa, Faculty of Law. We congratulate Megan and Emily on their achievement and look forward to working with them this summer when the internship takes place.

This is the twelfth  consecutive year that our firm has offered this Human Rights/Social Justice internship. Every summer, we provide paid employment to a student from the University of Ottawa Law School with placements in our firm and two social justice or human rights organizations. This year, Megan and Emily will be working with the Feminist Alliance for International Action (FAFIA) and the Economic and Social Council of Ottawa-Carleton. Previous placements for our internship have included the Workers’ History Museum, International Development Research Centre, EGALE Canada, Amnesty International, the Ottawa Coalition to End Violence Against Women, the Council of Canadians, REACH Canada, National Educational Association of Disabled Students and many other organizations which provide significant contributions in the areas of social justice and human rights.

Statement of Claim filed in Canadian Armed Forces sexual misconduct class action

The group of former military members who launched a class action regarding sexual misconduct in the Armed Forces has now filed a Statement of Claim in the Superior Court of Ontario. Amy Graham, Nadine Schultz-Nielsen, and Larry Beattie filed their full Statement of Claim on December 13, 2016, setting out their personal experiences of sexual assault and harassment, as well as the remedies that they are seeking on behalf of all class members.

The class action covers all current and former members of the Canadian Armed Forces who have experienced sexual assault, sexual harassment and abuse of power in the course of their education, training and service in the military. The Statement of Claim seeks compensation for affected members, as well as declarations and systemic orders against the government to change a system that condones a culture of sexual misconduct and punishes victims instead of perpetrators.

You can read more about the Statement of Claim here:

• CBC News: Sexual-misconduct lawsuit against Armed Forces alleges ‘reckless’ conduct

• Radio-Canada: Les Forces canadiennes visées par un recours collectif de 1 milliard de dollars

• Le Journal de Montréal: Un recours collectif d’un milliard $ contre l’armée

For more information, or if you or your family member may be affected by the class action, you can contact Raven Law at armedforcesclassaction@ravenlaw.com.