Category Archives: News

Federal Court of Appeal Overhauls Unjust Dismissal Law under the Canada Labour Code

The Federal Court of Appeal recently issued a decision overhauling the state of federal employment law. In Wilson v Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd, 2015 FCA 17, the Court  rejected the generally accepted approach to unjust dismissal complaints under the Canada Labour Code (“Code”), which applies to workers who are employed in federally regulated industries. The decision in Wilson has profound implications for non-unionized federally regulated employees. Mr. Wilson is currently seeking leave to appeal the Federal Court of Appeal’s decision to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Background on termination of employment of unionized and non-unionized employees

Unionized workers can only be dismissed with just cause

For most unionized workers, terms and conditions of employment are governed by collective agreements which include a requirement that the employer only terminate an employee where there is just cause for dismissal. Just cause is a high threshold for an employer to meet and provides substantial protection for unionized workers.

Non-unionized federal workers cannot be dismissed “unjustly”

Section 240 of the Code provides non-unionized federal workers with the right to make “unjust dismissal” complaints, provided they have been employed for at least 12 months and they allege that they have been dismissed “unjustly”. The Code also provides statutory remedies for federal workers who are dismissed unjustly, including reinstatement to employment, which are not available to non-unionized provincial workers.

Non-unionized provincial workers can be dismissed without cause

At common law, non-unionized employees who work for provincially regulated employers – the vast majority of employers in Canada – can be dismissed without cause provided that employers provide reasonable notice of termination, or pay in lieu or reasonable notice. A dismissal that is both without cause and without reasonable notice is a wrongful dismissal. Read more about termination in the provincial sphere here.

The Pre-Wilson Approach to Unjust Dismissal Complaints under the Code

Prior to Wilson, there was an established line of cases holding that federal employers could only dismiss employees for cause, similar to the just cause protections provided for in collective agreements. Leading employment law scholars, Innis Christie and Geoffrey England, have explained that the Code’s unjust dismissal provisions were intended to:

“provide the non-unionized employee with substantially similar protections against unjust discharge as the unionized employee enjoys under a collective agreement.”

However, Code adjudicators have disagreed on this point and there are conflicting decisions on whether the Code permits dismissals on a without cause basis. As Code adjudicators are bound by decisions of the Federal Court of Appeal, Wilson settles the disagreement, unless the Supreme Court of Canada grants leave to appeal and weighs in on the issue.

Wilson v Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd

A Code adjudicator determined that AECL had violated the Code by terminating Wilson on a without cause basis. AECL applied for judicial review of this decision at the Federal Court, and the Federal Court overturned the adjudicator’s decision. Mr. Wilson appealed the Federal Court’s decision to the Federal Court of Appeal.

A dismissal without cause is not “unjust”

In Wilson, the Federal Court of Appeal concluded that:

  • a dismissal without cause is not automatically unjust under the Code;
  • this is consistent with the common law of employment, which allows for dismissal without cause so long as the reasonable notice requirement is met; and
  • the Code cannot be interpreted as giving non-unionized employees a “right to the job” or attempting to place unionized and non-unionized employees in the same position.

Code adjudicators must determine if a dismissal is “unjust” in all of the circumstances

The Court also explained the role of Code adjudicators in unjust dismissal complaints:

  • it is up to Code adjudicators to look into the circumstances of each case to determine if the dismissal was “unjust”; and
  • adjudicators do not have “free rein” to find a dismissal unjust on any basis, although the fact that an employer has paid an employee severance pay does not preclude a finding that the dismissal was unjust.

However, beyond commenting that “unjust” is a term that “sits alongside and gathers much, if not all, of its meaning from well-established common law and arbitral cases concerning dismissal”, the Court declined to interpret the meaning of “unjust”. It will now be up to Code adjudicators to determine the meaning of “unjust” through the development of case law.

Supreme Court will decide whether to weigh in on this dramatic change for federal employees

The Federal Court of Appeal’s decision marks a major departure from an established line of cases, and creates considerable uncertainty in the law going forward. The Federal Court of Appeal left open the meaning of “unjust”, the very basis for section 240 complaints, which may now make it more difficult for a worker to assess the merits of an unjust dismissal complaint. Mr. Wilson’s leave application will thus be closely followed by federal workers and their advocates, who undoubtedly hope the Supreme Court will intervene on this important issue.

Some of the questions that may be raised, if the appeal is heard by the Supreme Court, include:

  • What, if any, differences are there between a common law wrongful termination and an unjust dismissal under the Code?
  • Is it contrary to the policy reasons for section 240 of the Code to permit terminations “without cause”?
  • Will reinstatement remain available as a remedy for unjust dismissal complaints under the Code, if employers are now permitted to terminate without cause? If so, under what circumstances will it be ordered?

It is hoped that an appeal before the Supreme Court will bring clarity to these issues, and resolve them in a manner that is consistent with the protections Parliament intended to afford to federally regulated employees.

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

Morgan Rowe Book Launch a Resounding Success

On May 14, 2015, Morgan Rowe and University of Ottawa Professor Ravi Malhotra celebrated the launch of the paperback version of their book, Exploring Disability Identity and Disability Rights through Narratives: Finding a Voice of Their Own. The event was a resounding success, with the first order of the book selling out before the end of the event. Morgan would like to thank everyone who came out and contributed to making the event such a success.

Continue reading →

Morgan Rowe Launches New Edition of her Book

Morgan Rowe will be celebrating the paperback launch of her book, Exploring Disability Identity and Disability Rights through Narratives: Finding a Voice of Their Own, on May 14, 2015. The book explores the relationship between disability, human rights, and personal identity in the lives of Canadians with disabilities. The book launch is being hosted by Octopus Books. More details about the event can be found here.

 

Andrew Astritis speaks at Accommodation Law Conference

Andrew Astritis will be presenting at the 2015 Accommodation Law Conference, hosted by Labour Law Online – Centre for Labour-Management Development. The conference, which takes place on April 22 and 23, 2015 at the Chateau Laurier in Ottawa, will address recent development in human rights and accommodation law, including a summary of recent cases in the area. More information on the conference is available here.

 

Court confirms that employers bear the onus to prove just cause for termination

It has long been established in labour arbitration jurisprudence that, when presented with a grievance concerning discipline, the employer bears the onus of demonstrating just cause for that discipline. In order to determine whether there is just cause for termination or another disciplinary sanction, Arbitration Boards will consider several factors which include, not only the factual circumstances, but also any aggravating and mitigating factors.

Recently, an Arbitration Board in Nova Scotia failed to properly apply the onus when considering whether an employer had just cause to terminate a unionized employee. In arriving at its conclusion to dismiss the grievance, the Arbitration Board found as follows:

Having found that the Employer had grounds to discipline the Grievor there remains the question of whether the termination of the Grievor was the appropriate response.

The onus is on the Grievor to show mitigating factors that should be taken into account if the penalty of discharge is to be substituted with another penalty.

The employee’s union, the Public Service Alliance of Canada, was concerned about the latter paragraph which indicated that the Arbitration Board improperly shifted the onus to the employee to prove that termination was not the appropriate penalty. The union applied for judicial review of the Arbitration Board’s decision to the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia. In its decision, Public Service Alliance of Canada v Commissionaires Nova Scotia, 2014 NSSC 286, the Court agreed with the union, holding:

The Board did not engage in the necessary analysis of the grounds for discipline, whether the misconduct was sufficiently serious to warrant a penalty as severe as discharge. The Board did not articulate both mitigating and aggravating factors and weigh these against the seriousness of discharge to determine if the respondent had met its burden.

The Board seems to have assumed the seriousness of the conduct warranted the penalty of discharge and then looked to the appellant to show why anything but discharge should be considered.

This is not the appellant’s burden. The Board has failed to discuss the substitution of the lower penalty by reviewing any mitigating factors, except long service. The Board did not weigh other factors in evidence, such as a previously clear discipline record or evidence of good character. Had the Board performed this analysis they may well have still concluded that no lesser penalty was appropriate, particularly in light of the grievor’s outright denial and lack of remorse.

The burden of proof on the employer in discipline and discharge cases is important: the relevant information regarding why the employee was terminated usually resides almost exclusively in the hands of the employer. Moreover, in the unionized context, where employees may only be terminated with just cause, employers must be held to their onus of proving that just cause existed when the union challenges the basis for the termination.

While one might assume that the onus in discipline cases is well established, and Arbitration Boards will properly apply the burden of proof, the judgment of the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia in this case affirms that the courts are willing to intervene on judicial review to ensure that arbitrators do, in fact, approach disciplinary grievances in the appropriate fashion.

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

“Manager” should be “narrowly construed”: CLC Adjudicator

On January 30, 2015, Adjudicator François Bastien, appointed pursuant to the Canada Labour Code, issued an important decision impacting all employees with supervisory duties working in federally regulated sectors.

Generally, employees who are unjustly dismissed can bring a complaint and have their grievance heard by an adjudicator appointed under the Canada Labour Code. Managers cannot avail themselves of this process.

In Timiskaming First Nation, the Employer brought a preliminary objection alleging that the employee, who worked as the Director General of the First Nation Government, was a manager. The Employer asked the Board to dismiss the complaint.

In dismissing the employer’s objection, the Board confirmed that “it is important to keep in mind that underlying it, is the notion underscored by the Federal Court […], that while undefined in the Code, ‘manager’ is a term that ought to be narrowly construed under that Code.” The Board further endorsed the fact that a broader interpretation of the term “manager” could exclude many employees from the benefits of the unjust dismissal provisions of the Code.

This decision underscores the importance of reviewing the particular context of every workplace before making a determination as to whether an employee can properly be characterized as a “manager” under the Code. The Board fully recognized that the employee in question performed many functions at a high level – but nonetheless dismissed the Employer’s objection on the basis that her role fell short of the test of independent action over a significant range of matters.

Through this decision, the Board provides all employees with supervisory duties working in federally regulated sectors much needed clarity with respect to their rights under the Code.

The employee in this case was represented by Wassim Garzouzi of Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne & Yazbeck LLP/s.r.l.

Court Overturns Arbitrator’s Award on Vacation Credits

In a recent decision, the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia quashed an arbitrator’s decision concerning employees’ entitlement to vacation leave in the collective agreement between the Public Service Alliance of Canada (“PSAC”) and Sydney Airport Authority. At issue before the arbitrator was whether the agreement provided that employees on ‘sick leave with pay’ continued to accrue vacation credits. The arbitrator found they did not. PSAC challenged this decision and the reviewing court concluded that the arbitrator’s award was unreasonable. The Court explained that the arbitrator failed to undertake a fulsome analysis of the intentions of the parties within the four corners of the agreement and apply the necessary interpretive principles.

PSAC was represented by Andrew Astritis and Michael Fisher.

 

RavenLaw writes guest blog post on Supreme Court’s Right to Strike decision

On February 10, 2015, Andrew Raven and Andrew Astritis wrote a guest blog post for the Broadbent Institute on the Supreme Court of Canada’s recent decision confirming the right to strike in Saskatchewan Federation of Labour v Saskatchewan. The blog post, available here, provides a summary of the Court’s decision and its broader implications for the labour movement.

David Yazbeck Participates in CIRB Consultation Committee

This week, David Yazbeck is participating in the Canada Industrial Relations Board (“CIRB”) Consultation Committee as the Canadian Association of Labour Lawyers (“CALL”) nominee. The Consultation Committee is an ongoing dialogue and consultation process between the CIRB and the labour community, established for the purpose of canvassing labour and management sides with respect to their expectations regarding industrial relations issues that concern them. The Consultation Committee includes members from CALL, the Canadian Labour Congress, Confédération des syndicats nationaux, the Canadian Association of Counsel to Employers, and Federally Regulated Employers in Transportation and Communications Organization, as well as the Chairperson and representatives from the CIRB.

 

Wassim Garzouzi Presents on Family Status

On February 13, 2015, Wassim Garzouzi spoke at the Network of Persons with Disabilities, organised by Reach Canada on the topic of “Duty to accommodate: Family Status.” The bilingual event was attended by over 250 participants from across the country.

Reach Canada has offered lawyer referrals and public education for individuals living with disabilities since 1981. Our firm is a long-term, proud supporter of REACH and its mission to improve the quality of life for citizens with disabilities.