Category Archives: News

Courts differ on whether to deduct CERB benefits from wrongful dismissal damages

Courts differ on whether to deduct CERB benefits from wrongful dismissal damages
By Raven Law
[The firm gratefully recognizes the contribution of this post by articling student
Anna Rotman]

The Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) was introduced in part to support
individuals who lost their jobs due to the pandemic. Millions of workers across
Canada who were out of work at some point during the pandemic have received
CERB payments. Some of those workers may have made claims of wrongful
dismissal against their employers and are seeking damages either through a
settlement or a court action. The question for those employees is: Will the CERB
payments be deducted from their damages for wrongful dismissal?

It was unclear when the CERB was introduced whether it would be treated like
income received during an employee’s notice period, and therefore deducted from a
damages award, or if it would be treated like Employment Insurance (EI) benefits,
which are not considered mitigation income.

There are now a handful of court judgments across Canada considering this
question, and, unfortunately, they have not all come to the same conclusion.


Judgments refusing to deduct CERB payments from damages awards


The Ontario Superior Court rendered one decision refusing to deduct CERB
payments from a damages award, but the reasoning in that judgment was very
fact–specific. In Iriotakis v Peninsula Employment Services Limited, Mr. Iriotakis
had been working as a salesperson and received most of his income through
commission. Due to a clause in the employment contract, the employer was not
obligated to pay him his commission during the reasonable notice period, leaving
him entitled only to his base salary. The judge stated that, based on these facts, it
would be inequitable to deduct the benefits he earned through CERB from his
damages. The Court was careful to note that this decision was based on the specific
facts of Mr. Iriotakis’s termination.

The Supreme Court of Nova Scotia has also refused to deduct CERB payments from
a damages award, on the basis that doing so would only benefit the employer and
could potentially harm the employee. By that time, the federal government had
made it clear that certain people would have to pay CERB back. In Slater v Halifax
Herald Limited, the Court was strongly influenced by the possibility that the
employee would be asked to pay the CERB back and would be put in a difficult
position. Furthermore, given the fact that CERB payments were meant to be income
replacement and could be subject to repayment, the Court found them to be
“analogous to EI benefits” and as such should not be considered in the calculation
of damages.

Judgments deducting CERB payments from damages awards

The British Columbia Supreme Court deducted CERB payments from damages for
wrongful dismissal in Hogan v 1187938 B.C. Ltd. Mr. Hogan had received $14,000
in CERB benefits in 2020 and the Court found that, if they were not deducted from
his wrongful damages, then he would be in a better financial position than he would
have been had the employer not fired him. The Court considered Iriotakis and
found that, unlike Mr. Iriotakis, Mr. Hogan’s employment contract did not limit his
damages and there was no equitable reason not to deduct CERB.

Furthermore, the Court distinguished CERB from employment insurance (EI) and
private insurance, neither of which are usually deducted from damages. First, the
employer and employee had not contributed to CERB and it was therefore not an
earned benefit. Second, the Court wrote, unlike EI, there was no obligation to pay
CERB back (this judgment was rendered before it became clear that CERB may
need to be repaid in some cases). It is thus unclear how the Court may have
decided had it been aware of the possibility that employees must repay CERB
benefits.

The Provincial Court of Saskatchewan also deducted CERB from wrongful dismissal
damages in Abdon v Brandt Industries Canada Ltd. Interestingly, it held that it
could not follow Iriotakis because the Ontario Superior Court seemed to have
reached its decision on an equitable basis and the Provincial Court of
Saskatchewan, being a statutory court, did not have equitable jurisdiction. This
decision potentially leaves it open for the Saskatchewan Court of Queen’s Bench to
follow Iriotakis since it does have jurisdiction to base decisions on equitable
principles.

Conclusion

The judgments so far considering whether to deduct CERB benefits from wrongful
dismissal damages have left a great deal of uncertainty for individuals. The unique
nature of these benefits seems to have left courts ill–equipped to account for those
benefits when determining an award of damages for wrongful dismissal.
We will be following closely as courts continue to grapple with this question. Consult
one of our experienced employment lawyers at Raven, Cameron, Ballantyne and
Yazbeck LLP if you collected CERB after termination and are concerned about the
damages you are owed for wrongful dismissal.

[This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice,
which cannot be given without consideration of your individual circumstances.]

Federal Court Rejects Anti-Abortion Challenge to Government Funding Restrictions

On October 22, 2021, the Federal Court dismissed an application by the Right to Life Association of Toronto and Area (TRTL), which sought to challenge the Federal Government’s decision to deny it funding for the 2018 Canada Summer Jobs program because its president refused to sign an attestation that the job and the organization’s mandate respected human rights, including reproductive rights. Continue reading →

Jessica Greenwood to Co-Chair Public Sector Bargaining Conference

On November 24, 2021, Jessica Greenwood will be co-chairing the Ontario Bargaining in the Broader Public Sector Conference, hosted by Lancaster House.
Jessica will be moderating panels on the economic forecast for 2022 and its potential impact on bargaining and on how the COVID-19 pandemic and the move to virtual meetings will impact bargaining processes. Other panels will address negotiations topics affecting workplaces in 2022, like post-pandemic health and safety concerns, and ways of improving bargaining processes for workers and employers.
The slate of presentations promises to be informative and extremely timely, as we hear about a shift towards greater bargaining power for workers and unions. Registration information can be found here.

Wassim Garzouzi Publishes Chapter on Collective Bargaining in Education

Wassim Garzouzi recently published a chapter in the edited collection, Collective Bargaining in Higher Education. Wassim’s chapter addresses the myth of academic exceptionalism in organizing and collective bargaining within academia, examined through the lens of a successful organizing drive and first contract achieved by the part-time law professors at the University of Ottawa.

The chapter is available here. The interest arbitration decision referred to in the chapter can be found here.

“Draconian and Inflexible”, Arbitrator Declares ORNGE’s Drug and Alcohol Policy to be Unreasonable and Discriminatory

The Office and Professional Employees International Union (OPEIU) was successful in two grievances challenging ORNGE’s Drug and Alcohol Policy. Specifically, the OPEIU challenged the ORNGE’s “zero-tolerance” approach to medical cannabis, and its practice to treat prescribed medicinal cannabis differently from other types of medication.

Arbitrator Gail Misra declared ORNGE’s policy to be discriminatory and unreasonable. She concluded that “having a blanket edict that if an employee can only use medical cannabis to treat their illness, they cannot do a safety sensitive job, is draconian and inflexible, and is not supported by the [Canadian Human Rights Act] or the jurisprudence.”

As a result, Arbitrator Misra declared the policy to be “unreasonable to the extent that it fails to treat prescribed medicinal cannabis as a “medication”.  Furthermore, “having found that Ornge’s inflexible position regarding cannabis use in a safety sensitive position is unreasonable, I also find that the Policy was drafted in a discriminatory manner in that it does not properly provide for accommodation to the point of undue hardship for those working in a safety sensitive position, who, due to their medical condition, are prescribed cannabis for medical treatment purposes.”

The OPEIU was represented by Wassim Garzouzi, Julia Williams and Patt Gibbs.

The decision can be accessed here.

Dayna Steinfeld Appears in Constitutional Challenge for First Nations Children

Dayna Steinfeld Appears in Constitutional Challenge for First Nations Children
Beginning on October 25, 2021, Dayna Steinfeld is appearing in the Manitoba Court of Queen’s Bench as co-counsel for the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs (AMC) in a case challenging the Manitoba government’s enactment of section 231 of The Budget Implementation and Tax Statutes Amendment Act (BITSA).
Section 231 of BITSA legislatively immunizes the Manitoba government from liability for taking more than $335 million of federal Children’s Special Allowance funds from Manitoba children in the child welfare system. In addition to extinguishing two existing court actions against the government, section 231 prohibits bringing any action, application or complaint and prohibits the granting of any remedy related to Manitoba’s actions.
Before the Court, AMC will argue that Manitoba, by enacting BITSA:
  • infringes the core jurisdiction of the superior courts and breaches section 96 of the Constitution Act, 1867 by absolving itself from any liability and denying First Nations children in care the right to access the courts;
  • denies First Nations children substantive equality and equal benefit of the law on the grounds of age, race, aboriginality-residence and family status, contrary to section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms;
  • denies First Nations the rights, benefits and opportunities promised to First Nations children in care by Canada pursuant to s. 91(24) of the Constitution Act, 1867 and has therefore passed law that is beyond the province’s constitutional authority; and
  • violates the honour of the Crown and breaches its fiduciary duty owed to First Nations children in care.
The case is being heard from October 25 to 29, 2021.